Difference between revisions of "ARP Issues in LVS/DR and LVS/TUN Clusters"
(→Problems) |
Bmontarges (Talk | contribs) (→Solutions) |
||
| (6 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
[[Image:Cluster-need-disable-arp-for-VIP-at-realservers.png|center]] | [[Image:Cluster-need-disable-arp-for-VIP-at-realservers.png|center]] | ||
| − | If we did not disable ARP for [[VIP]] address at real servers, there would be race condition in ARP response, then router might send requests for VIP to real servers directly instead of the load balancer. This would break the whole load balancing solution. | + | If we did not disable ARP for [[VIP]] address at real servers, there would be race condition in ARP response, the load balancer and the real servers may give ARP response for VIP simultaneously, then router might send requests for VIP to real servers directly instead of the load balancer. This would break the whole load balancing solution. |
| + | |||
| + | In a [[LVS/DR]] and [[LVS/TUN]] cluster of some special configuration illustrated in the following figure, real servers don't have any interfaces connected to the network that [[load balancer]] receives packets for [[VIP]], but have their router to transmit response packets, then there is no need to disable ARP for VIP at real servers, because there is no chances for real servers to receive ARP request for VIP. | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[Image:Cluster-not-need-to-disable-arp.png|center]] | ||
| + | |||
| + | Anyway, there is no hurt to disable ARP for VIP at real servers in any [[LVS/DR]] and [[LVS/TUN]] clusters. | ||
== Solutions == | == Solutions == | ||
| − | * arptables | + | === Linux === |
| − | * | + | |
| − | * | + | There are many solutions to disable ARP for VIP in real servers running the Linux operating system. |
| − | * | + | |
| − | * | + | * [[Using arptables to disable ARP]] |
| − | * | + | * [[Using arp_announce/arp_ignore to disable ARP]] |
| + | * [[Using the hidden interface to disable ARP]] | ||
| + | * [[Using redirect to disable ARP]] | ||
| + | * [[Using policy routing to disable ARP]] | ||
| + | * [[Using the noarp module to disable ARP]] | ||
| + | |||
| + | === FreeBSD === | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[LVS/DR]] and [[LVS/TUN]] clusters can work with FreeBSD [[real server]]s without any problems. See the article [[Disable ARP on FreeBSD]] for more information. | ||
| + | |||
| + | === Solaris === | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[LVS/DR]] and [[LVS/TUN]] clusters can also work with Solaris [[real server]]s without any problems. See the article [[Solaris Servers in LVS/DR and LVS/TUN Clusters]] for more information. | ||
| + | |||
| + | === Windows === | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[LVS/DR]] and [[LVS/TUN]] clusters can also work with Windows [[real server]]s without any problems. See the article [[Windows Servers in LVS/DR and LVS/TUN Clusters]] for more information. | ||
| + | |||
| + | === AIX === | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[LVS/DR]] and [[LVS/TUN]] clusters can also work with AIX [[real server]]s without any problems. See the article [[AIX Servers in LVS/DR and LVS/TUN Clusters]] for more information. | ||
== References == | == References == | ||
Latest revision as of 16:47, 10 April 2010
Problems
In the LVS/DR and LVS/TUN clusters, we can see that the VIP address is shared by load balancer and all real servers. In order to make the LVS/DR and LVS/TUN clusters work, load balancer should broadcast the VIP address to accept incoming packets for virtual service, the real servers only use the VIP address to process the packets for VIP locally.
The ARP problem arises when real servers have one of their interfaces connected to the network that LVS/DR and LVS/TUN load balancer receives packets for VIP. For example, a LVS/DR or LVS/TUN cluster of the following topology needs to disable ARP for VIP address at real servers.
If we did not disable ARP for VIP address at real servers, there would be race condition in ARP response, the load balancer and the real servers may give ARP response for VIP simultaneously, then router might send requests for VIP to real servers directly instead of the load balancer. This would break the whole load balancing solution.
In a LVS/DR and LVS/TUN cluster of some special configuration illustrated in the following figure, real servers don't have any interfaces connected to the network that load balancer receives packets for VIP, but have their router to transmit response packets, then there is no need to disable ARP for VIP at real servers, because there is no chances for real servers to receive ARP request for VIP.
Anyway, there is no hurt to disable ARP for VIP at real servers in any LVS/DR and LVS/TUN clusters.
Solutions
Linux
There are many solutions to disable ARP for VIP in real servers running the Linux operating system.
- Using arptables to disable ARP
- Using arp_announce/arp_ignore to disable ARP
- Using the hidden interface to disable ARP
- Using redirect to disable ARP
- Using policy routing to disable ARP
- Using the noarp module to disable ARP
FreeBSD
LVS/DR and LVS/TUN clusters can work with FreeBSD real servers without any problems. See the article Disable ARP on FreeBSD for more information.
Solaris
LVS/DR and LVS/TUN clusters can also work with Solaris real servers without any problems. See the article Solaris Servers in LVS/DR and LVS/TUN Clusters for more information.
Windows
LVS/DR and LVS/TUN clusters can also work with Windows real servers without any problems. See the article Windows Servers in LVS/DR and LVS/TUN Clusters for more information.
AIX
LVS/DR and LVS/TUN clusters can also work with AIX real servers without any problems. See the article AIX Servers in LVS/DR and LVS/TUN Clusters for more information.
